Housing Innovation: Ideas to Empower Communities (Techcrunch)
Discover how housing innovation can empower communities by creating sustainable, affordable living spaces for all.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Three Lessons from Tokyo Urbanism for Your City
A guide to Tokyo Urbanism, inspired by the EconTalk podcast, showing how to foster grassroots entrepreneurship.
This is part of a series about specific problem domains I find interesting and important.
Innovation Insights [DB]
List view
Three Lessons from Tokyo Urbanism for Your City
Social Determinants of Health and Cross-Sector Data Sharing (Brookings Institution)
City of the Future: Co-cities to Empower Communities (Fordham)
City of the Future: Empower Communities (Fast Company)
Responsible Tech: Empowering Communities Through Data Trust (Bloomberg)
The Future of Technology is in Highly Regulated Industries (Techcrunch)
Housing Innovation: Ideas to Empower Communities (Techcrunch)
Tokyo Urbanism: A Hidden Key to its Magic
Tokyo’s magic isn't an accident; it’s by design.
In Tokyo, there are five to ten times more local businesses, especially restaurants, per person than in a typical American city. This leads to an incredible range of choices and a steady sense of creative energy. It works because the city’s design gives more people the chance to follow their passions and create places that show real care and skill.
Without learning from cities like Tokyo, your own neighborhood might keep losing its most creative people and the spark that makes it unique. But by learning from Tokyo’s example, you can inspire new life in your community and make it more open, imaginative, and full of energy.
Key Takeaways
This guide summarizes the key takeaways from the EconTalk podcast episode "The Magic of Tokyo.” To replicate Tokyo’s success, Start with a Pilot Zone to prove the model works, Reframe the Conversation to build the political will for change, then Make Building Homes Predictable to solve the affordability crisis.
US Cities Face Three Roadblocks to Tokyo-style Urbanism
The Rules
Unlike Tokyo’s inclusive zoning, US codes are rigid and exclusive. In Tokyo, low-impact businesses can operate in almost any zone, but in the US, highly specific single-use zoning often makes mixed use illegal.
Our rules also require large minimum unit and lot sizes, along with strict building codes. These standards would ban Tokyo’s many affordable, space-efficient micro residential and commercial units and price out most of its creative entrepreneurs.
The Politics
Unlike most of Tokyo, our cities face strong NIMBYism, meaning many people resist changes in their neighborhoods. That makes it unrealistic to quickly update laws to match Tokyo’s approach.
Any talk of reform meets heavy political pushback, which traps us in a false choice between keeping things the same or growing, while Tokyo’s national zoning model allows both at once.
The Processes
Our process for approving new homes is a costly and uncertain political nightmare. It empowers a few vocal residents with veto power, which scares off most builders, except luxury housing providers.
Tokyo avoids this by having a predictable, administrative "by right" system, where projects that follow clear national rules get approved without political fights, making it much easier to build and uphold property rights.
Lesson 1 of Tokyo Urbanism: Start with a Pilot Zone
This lesson directly solves The Rules Problem by creating a small sandbox where you can test a simpler set of rules that benefit neighborhood entrepreneurs.
What This Is
A small, safe area where you eliminate minimum size requirements to allow for the tiny, adaptable, and affordable commercial spaces that are the secret sauce of Tokyo’s vibrant local economy.
After World War II, instead of criminalizing the city's informal black markets, the government gave these entrepreneurs tiny stalls with property rights. The government also made it radically cheap to start a business. In Japan, a simple $50 liquor license and cheaper rent can make the average cost to open a bar 4-10x cheaper than starting one in the US.
Why It Matters
These stalls ultimately evolved into the now famous Golden Gai district and its beloved yokocho alleyway shops. Grassroots commerce has become a treasured cultural asset driving economic growth.
Tokyo’s strategy also bypassed citywide political fights by creating a small, visible win. Its more flexible, bottom-up approach empowers local people to pursue their dreams and creates vibrancy, not chaos.
How You Can Use It
Use the Pilot Zone Playbook to design the experiment. Designate a small area as a pilot zone and provides the vendors with legitimate, tiny, low cost stalls with property rights. This turns a "problem" into a celebrated and permanent "Golden Gai" style district for her city.
Examples (Toggle for more)
- Less Productive Example: A city decides that a thriving but informal night market is a problem to be solved. They send in law enforcement to shut it down, criminalizing the small entrepreneurs and destroying a beloved community hub.
- More Productive Example: Maria, a city planner, uses the Pilot Zone Playbook. She replicates Tokyo’s post war success with informal black markets. Instead of a crackdown, she designates the area as a pilot zone, eliminates minimum size rules, and offers vendors legitimate, tiny, low cost stalls with simplified permits. After proving the ground floor model works, she pilots one zakkyo-like building, a term from Japan, which is a "vertical alleyway" with businesses on each floor, a powerful way to create density.
Lesson 2 of Tokyo Urbanism: Reframe the Conversation
This lesson directly solves The Politics Problem by changing the terms of the debate to bypass NIMBY gridlock.
What This Is
Shifting the political debate away from a losing battle like "density" to a winning one like "empowering local entrepreneurs." This means you stop arguing about abstract zoning codes and start telling human stories about the people who benefit from more flexible rules.
Why It Matters
NIMBY opposition often grows from vague fears. Reframing connects your policy to what people care about most and helps shape a clear vision of what a city should value.
In Japan, the story of the datsusara, meaning “escaped salaryman,” helps reframe success. It shows that a great city gives people freedom and security to leave rigid roles and follow their own paths. This is possible in Tokyo because a strong social safety net, including universal healthcare and affordable education, reduces the risks of change.
The same idea applies to how cities handle historic preservation. In the United States, preservation often freezes buildings in time, like creating a museum. Tokyo, by contrast, protects local people and their daily lives. Supporting a living community, where people can grow and adapt, is a more human and hopeful goal than guarding old buildings alone.
How You Can Use It
Stop arguing about zoning text and start telling human stories. Use the Coalition Builder Canvas to map potential allies and craft messages that appeal to their core values, not your policy jargon.
Examples (Toggle for more)
- Less Productive Example: An urbanist shows up to a community meeting with charts about density and gets into an argument, failing to persuade anyone and only deepening the political divide.
- More Productive Example: Maria uses the Coalition Builder Canvas. She tells the story of local creative entrepreneurs who opened a shop in her pilot zone. She frames the pilot as a way to preserve the city’s living community, not just its old buildings, and argues that this is the best way to empower local people to pursue their dreams. This powerful, human-focused message builds coalitions as diverse as local CDCs and the local Chamber of Commerce, just as it did in Japan.
Lesson 3 of Tokyo Urbanism: Make Building Homes Predictable
This lesson directly solves The Process Problem by replacing an uncertain, political process with a clear and reliable one.
What This Is
A “by right” development system means that if a building plan follows all the rules, it automatically receives a permit. In Tokyo, most housing follows this approach.
The system also allows large-scale growth through the Private Railway Model. In this Japanese model, private companies build both transit lines and the housing around them. This creates a sustainable cycle that funds infrastructure and makes neighborhoods walkable from the start.
Why It Matters
This removes the uncertainty that drives up housing costs. A predictable process is the key to grassroots affordability. Furthermore, a transit focused system means small businesses don't bear the high cost of building parking infrastructure, making their ventures more financially viable.
How You Can Use It
Advocate for your city to adopt a "by right" system for certain types of housing (such as “missing middle” housing) and locally-rooted, mom-and-pop landlords. Use a "By Right" Audit Checklist to analyze your city's current process and identify the specific bottlenecks that need to be removed.
Examples (Toggle for more)
- Less Productive Example: A developer in San Francisco spends years navigating meetings with neighborhood groups and "rent seeking politicians" for a code compliant housing project, only to have it vetoed, adding immense cost and uncertainty to the housing market.
- More Productive Example: Using the "By Right" Audit Checklist, Maria’s team identifies an ideal "by right" system and builds support among government, community, and business groups. She then shows these partners how they can file their plans with confidence that projects will be approved while avoiding major harms. If adopted, this clear process, combined with fewer parking requirements thanks to a new transit line, cuts costs and helps smaller local builders create much-needed housing and commercial spaces for local creative entrepreneurs.
Tokyo Urbanism FAQ
What is the core idea of Tokyo Urbanism?
It is a "bottom up" approach where the city grows organically from the choices of millions of individuals, not from a single top down master plan. It’s enabled by flexible, permissive rules that make it easy for people to open small businesses and build housing.
Is this just about copying Tokyo?
No. It’s about learning the universal principles behind Tokyo’s success—like empowering small entrepreneurs, making rules simple, and starting with low risk experiments—and applying them to your own community’s unique context.
How does this relate to housing affordability?
Directly. The same principles that make it easy to open a small shop, like "by right" approvals and no minimum unit sizes, also make it much easier and cheaper to build new housing, which is the key to solving the affordability crisis.
When should you NOT use this approach?
This approach is less effective for large scale, heavy infrastructure projects like building a new subway line or an airport. Those require significant top down planning and capital. Tokyo Urbanism is for revitalizing the human scale fabric of existing neighborhoods.
Dan Wu, JD/PhD
Lead Innovation Advisor
I help you innovate safely by making sure growth and governance go hand-in-hand.
SVP of Product & Chief Strategy Officer.
- As a go-to-market-focused product leader, I’ve led and launched products and teams at tech startups in highly-regulated domains, ranging from 6 to 8 figures in revenue.
- Led core products and product marketing key to pre-seed to E raises across highly-regulated industries such as data/AI governance, real estate, & fintech; rebuilt buyer journeys to triple conversion rates; Won Toyota’s national startup competition.
Harvard JD/PhD focused on responsible innovation for basic needs.
- Focus on cross-sector social capital formation, with a strong background in mixed-methods research.
- Selected as a National Science Foundation fellow & published on responsible strategy and innovation in outlets like Oxford University Press, Fast Company, and TechCrunch.
First-generation college student prioritizing inclusion and belonging in his practice.
- I was raised by a single mother without a high school degree.
- I’m passionate about mentoring and coaching using methods that “works with” (versus “do to”), sensitive to one’s constraints and experiences.
Related Posts
The Future of Technology is in Highly Regulated Industries (Techcrunch)
Explore the future of technology in highly-regulated industries. Discover how innovation is transforming healthcare, finance, and more while navigating complex regulations.
Responsible Tech: Empowering Communities Through Data Trust (Bloomberg)
Uncover the power of responsible tech in building data trust to empower communities
Made with Bullet